When he welcomed Benjamin in 2019, it was because he 'didn't want to wait' any longer to have kids. Never miss a story - sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. He told PEOPLE in 2019 he 'always knew wanted a family, but 'as a gay man, I never thought it was in the cards for me.' Starting a family, even as a single parent, has been a dream come true for the talk show host. Weeks after Lucy's birth, he shared on SiriusXM that Ben and Lucy are 'biological siblings,' though he did not use the same surrogate for the births. 'Little Wyatt Cooper gave her this maraca which she really loves,' Cohen shared of the toy his toddler couldn't put down, later admitting the toy could just be called a rattle.ĪLERIE MACON/AFP/Getty Ben and Andy CohenĬohen welcomed both his son and his daughter via surrogate. Seated on Cohen's lap, Lucy played with a balloon that the father-of-two said she 'loved,' as well as a maraca, which he revealed was a special gift from Anderson Cooper's son, Wyatt, who turned 3 on Thursday. He then turned to his smiling toddler and said to her, 'I really feel like you saw what I was doing and you let me try.' Related: Andy Cohen Enjoys Springtime at the Park with Daughter Lucy: 'Swinging Saturday' 'I did the hair this morning and you know what, she really submitted to it.' 'Just beginning Lucy's second year of life today,' the Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen host said as his toddler sat on his lap in her pajamas, pointing to the two small pigtails on Lucy's head. Later, in a video shared to his Instagram Story on Sunday, Cohen, 54, marked his daughter's new age as he sat with her at home. Bravo stars like Melissa Gorga, Kyle Richards, Luann de Lesseps, Cynthia Bailey, Tamra Judge, Lindsay Hubbard, Teresa Giudice, Gizelle Bryant, Porsha Williams, Dolores Catania, Garcelle Beauvais and Margaret Josephs, Candiace Dillard Bassett - among others - all commented with their best wishes, as did a few of Cohen's famous friends: John Mayer, Naomi Campbell, Jerry O'Connell and more.

Lucy is Lost by Ed King